Southampton’s Summer Transfer Dilemma: Who Should Be Kept, Sold, or Loaned?
Southampton are set for a major overhaul this summer. From players to backroom staff, the club must massively shift and separate itself from the horrors of the past season. To begin, the club must decide whether the players are capable or need to be sold for the best interest of the club.
Several factors need to be taken into account when making these decisions: contract situations, playing time, individual motivation to stay or leave, and the willingness to adapt to new manager Will Still’s philosophy. With these elements in mind, it’s time to assess the current squad and determine who should stay and who should go.
Goalkeepers
Aaron Ramsdale – The English international has been central to all twelve points Southampton have earned this season. Without the 27-year-old, the club would be in a far worse position. However, with reports suggesting he has no intention of playing in the Championship – and the chance to recoup his original transfer fee – it’s a loss the club must accept, especially given his high wages.
Verdict: Sell (£25m)
Alex McCarthy – His heroics during last season’s playoff run earned him a new two-year deal. While he may not be Premier League quality, the experienced Englishman remains a reliable option as a second-choice keeper in the Championship.
Verdict: Keep
Joe Lumley – Despite being the third choice, the 30-year-old made his Premier League debut this season. With his contract expiring this summer, a renewal makes sense to maintain depth in the goalkeeping department.
Verdict: Keep
Defenders
Jan Bednarek – Captain for much of the season, and it may have been his last on the South Coast. A reported £6m release clause, activated after relegation, has attracted interest from several clubs.
Verdict: Sell (£6m)
Jack Stephens – A poor start to the season saw him pick up two reckless red cards, but he’s since redeemed himself with improved performances. Committed to the club, he’s made his intentions clear to help lead Southampton back to the Premier League.
Verdict: Keep
Taylor Harwood-Bellis – Now represented by new agents, the Englishman is keen to remain in the Premier League. With West Ham reportedly monitoring him, a move seems increasingly likely.
Verdict: Sell (£20m)
Nathan Wood – His debut top-flight season has laid a solid foundation for a starting role next year. Signed for around £3 million, his steady performances have largely flown under the radar.
Verdict: Keep
Armel Bella-Kotchap – Injury problems have plagued much of his Southampton career. Though recently fit, his limited minutes reflect his poor form, and it’s widely reported he wants to leave the club.
Verdict: Sell (£7m)
Joachim Kayi-Sanda – Signed in January from sister club Valenciennes, the Frenchman has impressed with the under-21s, earning two senior Premier League appearances off the bench. One to watch next season.
Verdict: Keep
